How your LLC is taxed depends on decisions you’ve made, or haven’t made yet. Yarborough & Potter helps LLC owners across the Charlotte area understand their options, file accurately, and make smarter tax decisions throughout the life of the business.
Forming an LLC is one of the most common first steps for small business owners, and for good reason. The structure offers liability protection, operational flexibility, and something most business owners don’t fully appreciate until tax season: a choice in how the business is taxed.
A single-member LLC can be taxed as a sole proprietorship. A multi-member LLC is typically taxed as a partnership. And either type can elect to be taxed as an S-corporation or C-corporation. Each option carries different filing requirements, different rules around how you pay yourself, and different implications for how much you owe.
The problem is that many LLC owners make these decisions early on without fully understanding the tradeoffs, and then never revisit them as the business grows. Others don’t realize they have a choice at all. That’s where working with an accountant who understands LLC tax treatment makes a real difference. Not just at filing time, but throughout the year as questions come up about compensation, deductions, estimated payments, and structure.
Yarborough & Potter works with LLC owners at every stage. Whether you just formed your LLC and need help getting set up correctly, or you’ve been operating for years and want to make sure your tax position is as strong as it should be, our team can help.
The IRS does not have a dedicated tax classification for LLCs. Instead, your LLC is taxed based on how it’s classified, and in most cases, you have a say in that classification. Here’s how the most common options work.
By default, the IRS treats a single-member LLC as a “disregarded entity.” That means your business income and expenses are reported on Schedule C as part of your personal tax return. This is the simplest filing method, but it also means all of your business profit is subject to self-employment tax. For many LLC owners, this is the right setup early on. As income grows, though, it’s worth evaluating whether another classification would reduce your overall tax burden.
When an LLC has more than one owner, the IRS defaults to partnership treatment. The business files an informational return (Form 1065), and each member receives a Schedule K-1 that reports their share of income, deductions, and credits. Getting these allocations right is important. Mistakes here can create problems not just for the business, but for every individual member’s personal return.
Both single-member and multi-member LLCs can elect to be taxed as S-corporations. This is one of the most common strategies LLC owners use to reduce self-employment tax. Instead of all profit being subject to that tax, the owner pays themselves a reasonable salary (subject to payroll taxes) and takes remaining profit as distributions (which are not). It’s a real advantage when it fits, but it comes with added requirements around payroll, reasonable compensation, and corporate-level filing on Form 1120-S.
Less common for small businesses, but available. An LLC taxed as a C-corporation files its own return (Form 1120) and pays tax at the corporate level. Owners are then taxed again on any dividends, which is why this is sometimes referred to as “double taxation.” There are situations where it makes sense, but for most small LLC owners, it’s not the first choice.
Your LLC’s tax treatment is not locked in. If your business has changed since you formed it, your classification may deserve a second look. This is one of the most valuable conversations you can have with a qualified accountant.
LLC owners don’t need generic tax advice. They need someone who understands the specific rules, elections, and filing requirements that come with the structure.
The right classification depends on your income level, how you pay yourself, how many members are involved, and where you see the business going. Many LLC owners chose their structure when they first formed the business and haven’t revisited it since. If your revenue or situation has changed, it’s worth having that conversation with an accountant.
An S-corp election changes how your LLC is taxed so that not all of your profit is subject to self-employment tax. It can create real savings, but it also requires you to run payroll, pay yourself a reasonable salary, and file a separate corporate return. Whether it makes sense depends on your numbers. We can help you evaluate the tradeoff.
The most important first step is understanding how your LLC will be classified for tax purposes and whether the default treatment is the best option for your situation. From there, it’s about setting up good recordkeeping, understanding your estimated tax obligations, and knowing what deductions are available. A short conversation early on can save you a lot of trouble later.
Yes. Keeping your LLC’s finances separate from your personal accounts is important for tax purposes and for maintaining the liability protection the structure provides. Mixing the two can create problems at tax time and, in some cases, put your personal asset protection at risk.
That depends on how your LLC is taxed. Sole proprietorship LLCs take owner draws. Partnership LLCs distribute income to members based on the operating agreement. S-corp LLCs require a reasonable salary through payroll, with additional income taken as distributions. Getting this right matters because it affects both your tax liability and your compliance.
Unfiled returns can lead to penalties, interest, and escalating notices from the IRS or state. The longer you wait, the more complicated it gets. We work with LLC owners who are behind on filings regularly, and we can help you prepare the outstanding returns and get back on track.
Don’t ignore it, and don’t respond on your own without understanding what’s being asked. We can review the notice, help you understand what the IRS or state is looking for, and represent you throughout the process. Our team’s IRS background is especially valuable here.
Yes. We help LLC owners understand their resolution options and work toward a realistic outcome. That might involve a payment plan, penalty abatement, or another program depending on the specifics. The first step is understanding where things stand.
Yarborough & Potter is based in Charlotte, NC, and serves LLC owners across North and South Carolina. We’re happy to discuss your situation and see if we’re a good fit.
Whether you just formed your LLC or you’ve been running one for years, the right tax and accounting support can make a measurable difference in what you owe and how smoothly your business runs. If you have questions about your filing classification, your books, or your compliance, we’re here to help you work through them.
The consultation is free. No pressure, no jargon. Just a clear conversation about where your LLC stands and what the best next step looks like.
Yarborough & Potter Inc. is eager to answer your queries about our tax services. You can begin your relationship with us today by contacting us using the form below.
© Yarborough & Potter Inc. – Privacy Policy
License Numbers: 00076873-EA, 00091003-EA
